Laws of Malta.com
 
 
 
Malta Companies
Malta Shipping Centre
Malta Trusts
Malta Foundations
Malta Residence
Property & Real Estate
Online Gaming
eCommerce
Intellectual Property

Articles
 

Formation requirments of Maltese Holding companies
Submitted By : LawsofMalta

Date : 05 Nov  2010

MALTESE HOLDING COMPANIES - Formation Requirements and Taxation

 

The advantages of setting-up a holding company in Malta are gradually being realised by both resident and  non-resident shareholders. A holding company is, as its name suggests, a company which owns a  shareholding in another company or companies, either local or foreign, and distributes the income from  such shareholding to its shareholders in Malta or foreign.  Malta’s system of tax refunds and framework of double taxation treaties result in a tax efficient jurisdiction for holding companies, particularly those holding a participating holding in non-resident companies.  

 

This article provides a overview of the requirements for the registration of a holding company in Malta and the taxation applicable to such companies. 


FORMATION REQUIREMENTS 

 

 

The Memorandum and Articles of 

Association  

Like all other companies registered in Malta, a 

holding company has to have a memorandum 

and articles of association which must be 

registered with the Registrar of Companies 

at the Malta 

Financial Services Authority (

MFSA). 

 

Shareholders 

A holding company must have at least two 

shareholders, unless the company qualifies for 

private exempt status, in which case it may be 

set-up as a single member company. The

shareholders of the company may be either 

natural persons or bodies corporate. It is also 

possible for shares to held by a nominee or 

trustee on behalf of the shareholder.  

 

Share Capital  

A holding company must have an authorized 

share capital of not less than EUR 1,164.69 (or 

equivalent in foreign currency). At least 20% of

each share must be paid upon incorporation. 

 

As a general rule, the currency of the share

capital must be the company’s reporting 

currency for accounting and tax purposes. 

 

Subject to specific formalities, it is possible for 

the share capital to be issued for a non-cash 

consideration, provided that the considerationis capable of economic assessment and does

not consist of the provision of services. 

 

The Registered Office 

The registered office of the holding company must 

be in Malta.  

 

The Objects of the Company 

The memorandum of every company must contain 

an objects clause outlining the specific objects of

the company. The objects clause of a holding

company differs to that of other companies, since a

holding company will be holding shares in other

local and/or foreign companies. It is also possible

for the holding company to hold other assets, such 

as real estate, securities, intellectual property such

 

as trademarks and patents as well as other

intangible rights, irrespective of where such assets 

are located. 

 

Directors 

The holding company must have at least one 

director who may be either a natural person or a 

body corporate. As a rule, a sole director cannot 

 

occupy the post of company secretary, unless the

company has private exempt status, in which case 

 

the sole director can also act as company

secretary. 

 

Company Secretary 

Every company must have a company secretary, 

who must be a natural person. 

Meetings 

Every year a company must hold an annual general 

meeting. This annual general meeting need not be 

 

held on the anniversary of the previous annual general

meeting, provided that no more than fifteen months

elapse between one general meeting and another.  

 

Documentation 

The following documentation must also be supplied 

upon registration: 

a. Certified copies of relevant identification 

documents of shareholders and directors; 

b.  Deposit slip from a local or foreign bank 

following the opening of a corporate account 

 

for such amount corresponding to the paid up 

 

share capital; and 

c.  Document granting the powers of attorney in 

favor of any person signing the memorandum 

and articles of association on behalf of 

shareholders

 

The MFSA reserves the right to request the provision of 

any additional information. 

 

Fees 

Registration fee 

Upon registration with the Registrar, the holding 

company must pay the applicable registration fee 

 

which is calculated according to the value of its

authorised share capital. If registration is affected in

electronic format the registration fee ranges between 

Eur

210 to Eur 1,900 and Eur 245 to Eur 2,250 if 

registered in paper format.  

 

Registration of Annual Return 

Upon the registration of the annual return, the holding 

company must pay the applicable registration fee 

which again varies depending upon the authorised 

 

share capital of the company and whether registration 

is affected through electronic or paper format. 

 

Licensing Requirements  

It is possible that the holding company wishes to carry 

out an activity which is considered as a “licensable

activity” in Malta and would consequently necessitate 

 

application for the appropriate license or authorisation

from the competent authority. If this is not the holding 

 

company’s intention, it is essential that this is made 

clear in its memorandum and articles of association.  


TAXATION 

 

All companies registered in Malta are subject to 

corporate tax at a rate of 35% on their chargeable

income. However, Malta adopts a full imputation

system of taxation, through which tax paid by a 

 

company in Malta is imputed to its shareholders as a

tax credit upon the distribution of dividends. Thus, 

upon the distribution of dividends, the shareholders 

 

become eligible for a refund from the Commissioner of 

Inland Revenue, in whole or in part (depending upon

the circumstances as indicated below), of the tax paid 

 

by the company in Malta. Further tax relief may also 

apply via the application of the double taxation treaties 

 

which Malta has signed with over 50 countries, as well 

 

as the flat rate foreign tax credit for any tax that has been 

 

paid outside Malta.  

 

The “Participating Holding” Exemption  

Any income or gains derived by a holding company 

from a participating holding or from the disposal of the holding are exempt from income tax in Malta.

 

A "participating holding" exists when a Maltese 

company directly holds at least 10% of the equity 

shares in a non-resident company. If the Maltese 

 

company holds less than 10% of such shares it may

still qualify as a participating holding if the Maltese 

company satisfies any one of the following conditions:  

 

1. it has the option to call for and purchase, or enjoys 

the right of first refusal upon the disposal of, the 

remaining equity shares in the non-resident 

 

company; 

2. it is entitled to either sit or appoint a person to sit on 

the board of directors of the non-resident company; 

3. it invests at least EUR 1,164,000 (or equivalent in 

foreign currency) in the non-resident company  and

that investment is held for an uninterrupted period 

 

of 183 days; or 

4. it holds (not as trading stock) the shares in the non-

resident company in furtherance of its own 

 

business. 

 

The holding in the non-resident company must also 

satisfy any one of the following conditions (in addition 

to falling within the definition of a participating holding)

in order for the participating holding exemption to 

apply. Either the non-resident company: 

1. is incorporated in an EU Member State; 

2. is subject to foreign tax at not less than 15%; 

3. does not have more than 50% of its income

derived from passive interest or royalties;

4. (a) the holding of shares in the non-resident 

company is not a portfolio investment

and such 

 

non-resident company does not derive more than 

50% of its income from portfolio investments, and 

(B) the non-resident company or its passive 

interest or royalties is already subject to foreign

tax at a rate of not less than 5%. 

 

If none of the four above conditions are satisfied, the 

shareholders may, upon distribution of dividends, claim 

a five-sevenths refund of the advance tax paid by the 

company. 

 

The 6/7ths Refund 

Shareholders receiving dividends paid by a Maltese 

company are eligible for a six-sevenths refund of the

advance tax paid by the company, provided the 

 

company has not already claimed double taxation

relief, in which case the shareholders are no longer 

 

eligible to claim such refund. The six-sevenths refund 

 

results in an effective rate of Malta tax of 5%. 

 

The 5/7ths Refund for Passive Interest on Royalties 

Sha

 
   

On an upward curve: Malta's financial sector
Submitted By : Michael Imeson - FT Business

Date : 30 June  2010
While many of the world’s leading financial centres have suffered because of the financial crisis, a few smaller jurisdictions have been ticking along quite nicely, thank you. Malta is one of them.

It may be the European Union’s smallest state in population (414,000) and area (316 sq km), but it is one of the most economically stable and has avoided the ill-fortunes that have befallen many of its much bigger neighbours.

“In 2009, Malta was one of the top-five performing EU economies in terms of GDP,” Prime Minister Lawrence Gonzi told local and international financial services practitioners at FinanceMalta’s annual conference in April. Although the island’s GDP declined by 1.9% last year, the drop was small compared with elsewhere in Europe.

More fascinatingly, the financial sector boomed in 2009. “We have seen it grow by 22%, clearly a tremendous growth rate considering the background in which that took place,” said the Prime Minister. “Our financial system came out of the turmoil relatively unscathed, largely thanks to our robust and stringent regulatory framework and our adherence to sound banking principles.”

The country’s small size used to be a weakness, but it is now a strength. “For once in our long-chequered history, small is beautiful and we adapt using our size as our strongpoint,” said Dr Gonzi. If local or foreign firms have problems, they can sit down “with the relevant minister and his top people to design tailor-made solutions, rather than the government implement safety packages or fiscal incentives around the whole island as if it was butter on toast, benefiting those who did not necessarily require support.

“Because technology has bridged the whole world, the size of the space we occupy has become a secondary matter. Within the services sector, if we use technology, if we use education, we can compete with anyone around the globe.”

Vision 2015
The financial sector contributes around 12% to GDP, but under the Vision 2015 initiative the aim is to increase that to nearer 25% by 2015. According to the World Economic Forum’s “Global Competitiveness Report 2009-2010”, Malta ranks 13th for financial market sophistication and 13th for soundness of the banking system.

The country has 24 banks, 15 other financial institutions providing banking services but not licensed to take deposits, around 40 insurance companies, 401 funds, 81 fund managers and 13 fund administrators. Most of them are foreign owned.

Kenneth Farrugia, chairman of FinanceMalta, the public/private body that promotes the financial sector, told conference delegates that 105 new funds were authorised in Malta last year, an increase of 25% on 2008. “Other jurisdictions, like Luxembourg and Dublin, faced contraction. Here we experienced continuous growth.”

Twenty new investment services licences were issued in 2009, a 50% increase on what we had four years ago,” added Mr. Farrugia. “And although our regulations allow for fund managers to appoint foreign fund administrators, 47% of funds in Malta are administered here. That is an important attestation of the quality of service provided by our fund administrators.”

Banif demonstrates the potential
Perhaps the last word should go to Banif, the Portuguese bank that set up in Malta two years ago to serve local people and businesses. Joaquim Silva Pinto, chief executive of Banif Bank (Malta), says there were three reasons for the decision: Malta’s eurozone membership augured well; its “banking sector presented an interesting opportunity”; and the Banif group had taken a strategic decision to expand into other countries.

Malta is already well served by Bank of Valletta and HSBC, but Mr Silva Pinto is not deterred. “We are striving to become a key player in the Maltese market by capitalising on the knowledge and expertise gained from other places with the same economic and social characteristics, like Azores and Madeira,” he says.

Mr Pinto claims the first two years have gone “smoothly”. The bank is “now engaged in a rapid expansion of the branch network and the completion of the core package of banking solutions”. By the end of 2009 it had increased its lending portfolio five-fold compared with the end of 2008, and its deposit base seven-fold.

Banif Bank (Malta) took the unusual step of sponsoring the Malta football team in two World Cup qualifying matches – unusual in that they were against Banif’s home side, Portugal. But Mr Silva Pinto says it was a “natural” decision because it emphasised the bank’s “commitment to strengthening the relationship between Malta and Portugal”. The bank also sponsored and co-organised the Malta President’s Charity Fun Run.

With that sort of dedication to the local community, Banif seems bound to take market share off its competitors and profit from its presence on this small but dynamic island.

Michael Imeson, Associate Editor, FT Business



This article: "On an upward curve: Malta's financial sector" has been taken from the June 2010 edition of Financial World online. https://www.financialworld.co.uk/Archive/2010/2010_06June/Comment/Michael%20Imeson/18694-print.cfm

 
   

Trusts in Malta
Submitted By : LawsofMalta

Date : 23 July  2010
Trusts in Malta are regulated by the Trusts and Trustees Act which enables both residents and non‐residents to set up various types of trusts in Malta. Maltese trust legislation places great responsibility on trustees resident or operating in Malta. An individual or a corporate entity acting as a professional trustee and which is resident or operating in Malta, must be approved and licensed by the Malta Financial Services Authority. This licensing requirement means that licensed trustees have a high degree of responsibility especially in ensuring that trusts under their administration are fully compliant with the law, including all disclosure requirements in terms of antimoney laundering laws. Due to this approach, Maltese trusts are not registered in a centralised trust register. The great onus placed on trustees emanates also from the fact that trustees must not only act with diligence and attention but must act with the utmost good faith.

What is a trust?
A trust is a legal relationship created by a person, the settlor, who places assets under the control of a trustee, who undertakes an obligation to administer that property for the benefit of a beneficiary/ies or for a particular purpose.
Trust assets are offered protection by law as the property held in trust constitutes a separate patrimony from the assets of the trustee, ascertaining that the personal creditors of the trustee shall have no recourse against the trust property. Furthermore, the property of a particular trust is also segregate from property of another trust held by the same trustee. Importantly, the trust property shall not form part of the trustee’s personal estate upon his insolvency or bankruptcy and the trust property shall not form part of the matrimonial property of the trustee or his spouse nor part of the trustee’s estate upon his death.

Formation of trusts
In terms of Maltese law, a trust can come into existence in any manner. However, a unit trust must be set up in writing. However it is always recommendable to have a written trust deed or declaration so that this clearly delineates the parameters of the trust and the functions and discretions of the trustee. A trust shall continue until the 100th anniversary of the date of its creation and unless already terminated shall terminate then. This limit does not apply to trusts set up for
charitable purposes or unit trusts.

Under Maltese law, the beneficiary or beneficiaries must be identifiable by name or ascertainable by reference to a class or to a relationship to some person. The settlor of a trust may also be a beneficiary under the trust. A trustee is normally
precluded from being a beneficiary of a trust apart from specific trusts utilised in a financial services context and known
as commercial trusts. A trustee may benefit under a trust where he is not the sole trustee and in those cases where he is,
he may still benefit if he has prior approval of the MFSA or the court. Maltese law also provides for the possibility of having a protector in a trust relationship. Such a protector is designated by the settlor so as to supervise the operation of the trustees in terms of the trust deed.

Applicable law
The terms of the trust may identity the law applicable to the trust. Furthermore through the adoption of the Hague Convention on the Law Applicable to Trusts and on their Recognition, Malta recognises trusts having a foreign proper law. Where the proper law of a trust is foreign law, the validity of the trust, its construction, its effects and the administration of the trust shall be governed by such foreign law and shall be recognized and given effect to in Malta in accordance with Trusts the Hague Convention on the law applicable to trusts and on their recognition.

Types of trusts
There are three types of trusts, namely, an express trust, an implied trust and a constructive trust.
  1. An express trust is one in which the intention of the settlor to create the trust relationship is clearly and openly expressed.
  2. An implied trust arises from the unexpressed but presumed intention.
  3. A constructive trust arises by operation of law and is not dependent on the intention of the settlor.
Trusts can be tailor‐made for a number of uses. Trusts may be used for such purposes as asset protection, wealth management, investment purposes, to provide a life annuity for a surviving spouse or a child with special needs. Maltese law allows such a flexible use of the trust concept and details out specific safeguards to ensure the protection of settlers, beneficiaries and the trust property.

Commercial trust
The trust legislation also envisages the use of trusts for commercial purposes or commercial transactions. The law identifies a number of scenarios qualifying as commercial transactions such as the use of trusts for:
• Collective Investment Schemes,
• Securitisation of assets,
• Granting of real or personal security,
• Securities offerings, whether to the public or for private placement,
• Portfolio management,
• Custody of investment instruments,
• Syndicated loan agreements and other multi‐creditor banking facilities; and
• Insurance policies and the payment of proceeds thereunder.
Commercial trusts are afforded a greater flexibility than normal trusts, making these a suitable tool in the financial industry.

Taxation
Trusts are considered to be transparent for tax purposes if the income of the trust is distributed to the beneficiaries. In that case the income of the trust is not charged to tax in the hands of the trustee but is taxed in the hands of the beneficiaries. Where all the beneficiaries of a trust are not resident in Malta and where all the income attributable to the trust does not arise in Malta, there is no tax impact in terms of Maltese law. Income attributable to a trust which is not distributed to the beneficiaries is taxed in the hands of the trustees at a rate of 35%.

For further information please contact us on
info@lawsofmalta.com
 
   

Taxation of companies registered in Malta
Submitted By : LawsofMalta

Date : 06 Aug  2010
Taxation of companies registered in Malta

Companies, registered or resident in Malta, are subject to income tax on chargeable income at a standard rate of 35% ‐ known as Advanced Company Income Tax (ACIT). However, in view of Malta’s full imputation system of taxation any income tax paid by the company is credited in full to the shareholder upon a distribution of profits, so as to avoid any double taxation of corporate profits. The full imputation system, which has been utilised since 1948 and which is fully compliant with EU directives and ECJ case law, ensures that both resident and non‐resident shareholders are entitled for a refund of any tax paid by the company which is in excess of the shareholder’s income tax liability.

Income tax is paid in the same currency as the company’s share capital, which is also the currency in which the company prepares and submits its audited financial statements. The tax refund is also paid in the same currency, thus eliminating any currency exchange risks. In terms of the provisions of the income tax legislation, a tax refund must be paid by the Inland Revenue Department within 14 days from the end of the month in which it falls due.

Tax accounting
The income tax system utilizes different tax accounts for different sources of income namely the Final Tax Account (FTA), the Immovable Property Account (IPA), the Foreign Income Account (FIA), the Maltese Taxed Account (MTA) and the Untaxed Account (UA).
The attribution of chargeable income to the different tax accounts is an important aspect of the Maltese tax system as this determines the possibility of tax refunds upon a distribution of profits. Distributions from the FTA, the IPA and the UA do not give rise to any tax refunds in the hands of the shareholders, however, a distribution from the FIA and MTA entitles the shareholder to claim a refund which is equivalent to either 2/3rds, 5/7ths, 6/7ths, or 100% of the company income tax.
Profits attributed to the FTA include income that has been subject to a final withholding tax, profits arising from capital gains on immovable property which has suffered the property transfers tax, certain investment income and certain tax free profits. Profits attributed to the IPA are those profits resulting from the use of immovable property situated in Malta and which have not suffered the final withholding tax, profits from the rent, accommodation revenue by hotels and similar establishments, management fees and annual rental value of immovable property in Malta.
A company’s trading or passive income which is not attributable to the FTA and IPA, is attributed to the FIA or the MTA depending on the source of such income. A distribution from the FIA or MTA enables the shareholder to apply for a tax refund of the company tax.

Tax refunds
A tax refund is considered to fall due when the company’s audited financial statements (showing the dividend distribution) and a complete and correct income tax return are submitted to the tax authorities, the tax liability is paid in full and an application for refund on a prescribed form, together with the dividend certificate is submitted by the shareholder of his attorney or representative. Holding companies and the participating exemption

Holding companies that derive dividend income or capital gains from a ‘participating holding’ may apply for a participation exemption. Alternatively, the Maltese holding company may elect to be subject and pay income tax and upon a distribution of profits the shareholder is entitled to claim a full refund of the company income tax. This means that the shareholders may achieve an effective tax rate of up to 0%. A shareholding in a non‐resident company qualifies as a ‘participating holding’ if the Maltese company holds equity shares in a non‐resident company or a qualifying body of persons and it:
i) has a least 10% of the equity shares in the non‐resident company; or
ii) is an equity shareholder in the non‐resident company and is entitled to purchase the balance of the
equity shares of the non‐resident company, or it has the right of first refusal to purchase such shares; or
iii) is an equity shareholder in the non‐resident company and is entitled to either sit on the Board or appoint a person on the Board of that subsidiary as a director; or
iv) is an equity shareholder which invests a minimum in the non‐resident company of Lm500,000 (or the equivalent in a foreign currency) and such investment is held for a minimum uninterrupted period of 183 days; or
v) holds the shares in the non‐resident company for the furtherance of its own business and the holding is not held as trading stock for the purpose of a trade.
Furthermore the non resident company in question must either satisfy any one of the following three conditions:
‐ it is resident or incorporated in the EU,
‐ it is subject to foreign tax of a minimum of 15%,
‐ it does not derive more than 50% of its income from passive interest and royalties, or must satisfy both of the following conditions:
a) the non‐resident company or its passive interest or royalties have been subject to tax at a rate which is not less than 5%.
b) the shares in the non‐resident company must not be held as a portfolio investment; and


Companies having trading & certain types of passive income
Shareholders in receipt of dividend income emanating from companies having trading activities and certain types of passive income and whose profits are allocated to the FIA or MTA may apply for a tax refund equivalent of 6/7ths of the company tax paid, except where the income is deemed to be ‘Passive interest or royalties’, or double taxation relief has been claimed on such income. This means that the effective tax rate can be reduced to 5%.
ʺPassive interest or royaltiesʺ refers to interest or royalty income which is not derived, directly or indirectly, from a trade or business, where such interest or royalties have not suffered or suffered any foreign tax, directly, by way of withholding, or otherwise, at a rate of tax which is less than five per cent (5%);

Passive interest & royalties
When the income is deemed to be passive interest or royalties the rate of refund possible is of 5/7ths of the Malta tax paid – resulting in an effective tax rate of 10%. Alternatively companies receiving passive interest and royalties may reduce such 10% by applying the Flat Rate Foreign Tax Credit (FRFTC). The FRFTC is a deemed foreign tax of up to 25%. When the FRFTC is applied a refund of 2/3rds of the Malta tax paid on distributions from the FIA is possible hence resulting in an ultimate tax rate of 6.25%.

Advance Revenue Rulings
Certainty can be sought on important aspects through the request of an Advance Revenue Ruling from the International Tax Unit of Inland Revenue Department. Such ruling is valid for a period of five years and is renewable for a further five‐year period. The ruling is not mandatory however it not only confirms the tax authorities’ interpretation but also serves to preserve the same tax treatment for two years should there be a change in legislation which may affect the company or its tax treatment.
Other important considerations
‐ Malta has no specific transfer pricing rules;
‐ Malta has no capital duty and wealth taxes;
‐ Malta does not levy any withholding taxes;
‐ Malta has no thin capitalization rules or debt‐to‐equity ratios;
‐ No stamp duties on share transfers in companies owned by non‐residents;
‐ Non residents are exempt from any capital gains on certain share transfers;
‐ As an EU Member State Malta has adopted the EU’s Parent‐Subsidiary Directive and the Interest and Royalties Directive;
‐ Under the re‐domiciliation provisions it is possible to migrate companies into and out of Malta;
‐ Malta’s has strong and effective Money Laundering Laws and Regulations
‐ Malta’s legislation offers regulated professional trustees which may provide fiduciary and trust services
‐ No exchange control regulations and business may be conducted freely in any currency;
‐ Malta’s financial services legislation and tax laws are complaint with EU directives;


For further information contact us on info@lawsofmalta.com

 
   

Professional Services in the EU
Submitted By : MFSA

Date : 25 June  2010

Where can professionals work in the European Union? Will my professional qualification  allow me to work anywhere in the European Union?    

 

These are among the most frequently asked questions by Europe’s professionally qualified people and they are asked by, among many others, bankers, accountants, doctors, dentists and lawyers. Now, inevitably, Malta’s professionals are asking the same questions. 

 

Very broadly speaking, European single market legislation gives all EU citizens the freedom and right to work in any Union country. But there are two important caveats. The first is that the arrangements that Malta has negotiated with the EU mean that Malta’s own internal labour can be protected for some years to come; which is discussed later in this article. The second caveat concerns the mobility of professional qualifications and in this case the short answer is there is no short answer. 

  

An understanding of the European Union rules governing mutual recognition of diplomas and other professional qualifications is central to the understanding of whether a professional from a member state will be free to practice in any member state. The 

rules for lawyers, which are particularly complex, are considered important for a general understanding of the principles governing so-called “migrant professionals” in European Union member states. 

 

Recognition of  qualifications 

 

A professional person can have qualifications from any country in the world, but the only qualifications recognised and protected under EU law are those obtained inside the EU. Once Malta joins the European Union all professional qualifications obtained in the country, whether before or after European Union membership, will be considered European Union qualifications. 

 

Under EU Directive 89/48 law graduates have a right to see their national degrees recognised in another member state. Mutual recognition between member states of each other’s professional qualifications is automatic for craftsmen, farmers, doctors, dentists, general care nurses, midwives, veterinarians, pharmacist, and architects. It is also automatic for lawyers practising under their “home state” professional title, although unlike the others, they are not subject to prior co-ordination of training. So, a lawyer licensed to practice German law may provide German law advice in Portugal, Finland, Malta or any other member state.  

 

Besides the first two professions listed above, mutual recognition of the others is covered by specific European Union directives which provide the minimum acceptable conditions of education and training that have been co-ordinated by member states.    

 

However, certain professions are not guaranteed automatic recognition of their qualifications and as such come under the General System Directives. They are: engineers, physiotherapists, teachers, accountants, fiscal advisors, designers, and urban planners.  In these cases member states have the right to impose a so-called “compensation” if they believe the competence of the “migrant” professional is lower compared to that of their own professionals. This compensation gives the migrant the right to choose between an aptitude test and/or a period of supervised practice.  

 

There are two principal Directives that come under the General System referred to above. One is 89/48, which recognises higher education diplomas awarded on completion of professional education and training of at least three years duration. The second is 92/5, which relates to qualifications obtained after more than three years university or lower level education, including secondary and primary education. Essentially professionals who come under the General System Directive category need to have fulfilled these Directives to the satisfaction of the member state receiving the professional, which also accounts for an individual’s professional experience. Any significant difference gives rise to further training and examinations. 

 

It also noteworthy that some professions are covered neither by the General System or the automatic recognition system, however, there are still varying deadlines for implementation of recognition throughout the European Union of qualifications relevant to particular professions. For instance, recognition of medical qualifications – enabling free movement of doctors came into force on January 1 2003.   Most others though have already been implemented. For architects there was a staged process of implementation of the various diplomas and other qualifications between 1989 and 1999. Acceptance is subject however to such points as proof that architects are covered by professional indemnity. 

 

 

Practising the profession in the EU 

 

According to European Union Directive 98/5 which provides for the freedom of establishment of qualified lawyers, lawyers qualified in one member state can also establish themselves in another member state. The Council of the Bars and Law Societies of the European Union have issued guidelines on the implementation of this Directive.    

 

There is clear distinction between obtaining recognition of a degree granted in one member state and exercising the profession in another.  For instance, an Italian law graduate can obtain recognition of his Italian law degree in, say, the Netherlands but cannot practice Dutch law unless he also qualifies as a Dutch lawyer following completion of the local requirements in the Netherlands. Essentially, lawyers in the European Union can provide their services in all member states and that includes appearing in courts and at tribunals provided they satisfy the requirements of the member state in which they are working.    

 

A lawyer qualified in Sweden can register at the Spanish Bar and practice Swedish and European Union law there under his Swedish title, but not Spanish law, unless he or she specifically qualifies in Spanish law by going through an approved conversion procedure. This is done through what is called an “equivalent procedure” which normally also includes a formal examination and after a three year familiarity period.  A more or less similar procedure exists in all the member states. 

 

The equivalent procedure in Italy for lawyers qualified in another member state to practise in Italy is established under Decreto Legislativo 96/2001 (http://www.gustizia.it/cassazione/leggi/dlgs96_01.html).    Any foreign lawyer wishing to practice in Italy must first go to the application procedure to be included in the Sezione Speciale of the Albo degli Avvocati.   Inclusion in the Sezione Speciale does not mean the lawyer can practice without restriction.  The law specifies certain restrictions: 

 

the lawyer can only represent an Italian client if he acts in association stipulated in private writing with an lawyer qualified in Italy; 

representation in front of the superior courts – other member state lawyers can only assume counsel for a client if after 3 years registration in the Sezione Speciale of the Albo degli Avvocati and having practised in a regular and effective manner and a request is made to the  Consigllio Nazionale Forense.  Applicants must prove that they have practised for at least 12 years experience (in and beyond Italy). Applicants have to take an aptitude test - an examination to ascertain a candidate’s professional abilities and capability to exercise the profession in Italy.  Candidates may be exempted from this examination if they are able to prove that they have  practised Italian, European and International law for a period of three years. 

 

In the England and Wales, lawyers qualified in other member states have to take a conversion test and meet a two year experience requirement which may be waived/reduced under certain conditions. (http://www.lawsociety.org.uk).   The Qualified Lawyers Transfer Test covers four Heads: 

 

Head I Property 

Head II Litigation 

Head III Professional Conduct and Accounts 

Head IV Principles of Common law 

 

Notaries an anomalous position 

 

There is one group of European professionals, though, who do not have complete freedom of movement.   These are the notaries. They are restricted by several criteria, including the so-called “nationality criteria” which means notaries in certain member states face more restrictions than others. It’s not at all clear why notaries should be different from all other professionals. It is likely that the law will be changed, either as a result of a court finding or through the normal legislative process. A person qualified as a lawyer and as a notary as in the case of Malta should be able to operate as a lawyer in any European Union country, but in some of the countries he won’t be able to act as a lawyer and as a notary but has to choose between the two, as is already the case in Malta. 

 

It is clear that in the case of lawyers there is distinction between the type of practice they can provide in a member state outside their country of qualification.   They can only provide ‘’full’’ practice if they conform to local requirements, which generally include an examination and a qualifying local practising period, as explained above in the case of Italy and England and Wales. This requirement is more or less similar in all the member states. Such examinations will almost certainly be in the local language of the country where the ‘’migrant’’ lawyer wishes to carry out the ‘’full’’ practice.  

 

It appears that the Malta Chamber of Advocates perhaps in conjunction with the Faculty of Law of the University of Malta has still to establish what the local requirements for foreign lawyers who want to work in Malta are going to be.  

 

Malta’s accession to the European Union should prove exciting for the Maltese legal profession.   Qualifying in another country, providing that the language barrier can be overcome is not in itself a huge difficulty – after all, students qualified in Scottish law who want to work in England have been successfully converting to being English lawyers for nearly 300 years.  

 

The minefield of local requirements in the member states means that moving to another EU jurisdiction is not something to be lightly undertaken, but for those who want to experience working in their chosen field in another country the barriers are far from insurmountable.  

 

Professionals seeking to work in Malta 

 

For non-Maltese professionals and non-professionals wishing to come here things, at least initially, are not so straightforward.  While European Union workers will have the right to work in Malta, this right may be limited as follows:  

 

until 2011, Malta can refuse their work permits if there is a serious threat to local jobs; 

after 2011, Malta can still seek to restrict employment immigration, this time acting with the European Union. 

 

 

EU law will give Maltese people the freedom to work anywhere in the Union. That freedom and the right to have professional qualifications recognised across the EU are protected in law. 

 

Perhaps for the Maltese legal profession the future may be more about being part of EU and international alliances than about working in other jurisdictions. As Malta grows in importance – as a member state, as a finance centre and as part of the huge European single market – the demand for Maltese legal advice is bound to increase. 

 
   
 

 

 
 
Malta Articles
 
Formation requirments of Maltese Holding companies
posted on 05 Nov  2010 | by LawsofMalta
On an upward curve: Malta's financial sector
posted on 30 June  2010 | by Michael Imeson - FT
Trusts in Malta
posted on 23 July  2010 | by LawsofMalta
View more..
Malta Blogs
New Justice Portal for EU
posted on 23 Oct  2010 | by LawsofMalta.com
LawsofMalta.com
posted on 24 March  2010 | by Lawsofmalta.com
View more..
Links